BIG IDEA:
Even more important than the personal accountability of your team members is the team’s collective accountability.
Tom Brady and I are both doing some reflecting on our careers this month. In February of 2012, I began writing blogs about leadership accountability. At the time, I never would’ve thought I’d be at it for a decade.
Over those ten years, I was inspired by many leaders who embraced accountability as the cornerstone of their leadership. As my regular readers know, at the forefront of these leaders is NFL quarterback Tom Brady.
Brady inspired my very first blog post, which I published on February 5, 2012, just after the New England Patriots lost to the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLVI. And now, as I mark the ten-year anniversary of my blog, Brady has recently announced his own major milestone: he’ll be stepping away from the game.
Over the years, I’ve returned to Brady’s example, again and again, pointing out how his actions consistently demonstrated strong accountability as a leader:
- In 2015, I wrote about his mental toughness, after the Patriots won the Super Bowl again, and he was named Most Valuable Player.
- Then, in 2017, I wrote about the team’s ability to unearth hidden talent in athletes others hadn’t believed could be successful.
- And in 2021, I wrote about how Brady makes those around him better.
I recently discovered that even after four posts exploring the many facets of Brady’s leadership accountability, I had even more to learn—and to say—about his singularity in this area.
While watching the ESPN+ documentary series “Man in the Arena,” which chronicles Brady’s career, I noticed a pattern: as former teammates and coaches spoke to Brady’s ability to be personally accountable, they also repeatedly emphasized how he inspires the same in others.
As I reflected on this pattern, I began to reflect on the best teams I had the pleasure of being on in my own career. These were the ones where each team member demonstrated both personal and—even more importantly—collective accountability.
WHY IT MATTERS:
The best leaders create an atmosphere in which everyone on the team plays a role in holding the whole group accountable.
In my book Accountable Leaders, I write that on many teams, accountability is entirely rooted in the team leader. Accountability only happens if the team leaders push it and if those leaders work to hold each team member accountable.
This is certainly critical, but I’ve learned that it’s even more powerful when team members hold each other accountable. It takes hard work to get there, but I’ve seen that it’s possible.
For a picture of what collective accountability looks like in action, consider episode three of “Man in the Arena”, which tells the story of the New England Patriots’ Super Bowl win in 2004. Teammates Tedy Bruschi and Mike Vrabel were featured in the episode, and both provided example after example of how the team brought an overarching “edge” mentality, which referred to the team’s collective competitiveness, all anchored on personal accountability.
Players would show up to practice early, stay late, and push themselves to work harder—all to set the tone and inspire and challenge other team members to do the same. This collective sense of accountability led the Patriots to be a dominant team and repeat champions.
THE IMPACT:
Personal accountability is not enough to win the Super Bowl—or to achieve other momentous goals.
This is the fundamental lesson of Brady’s entire career. He clearly set the tone of accountability at a personal level and has some downright impressive superlatives to show for it: over the course of his career, he has been to ten Super Bowls, more than any other player. He’s won seven of them, again, more than any other player. He’s also won five MVP titles in Super Bowl games—once again, more than any player.
But at the end of the day, you don’t win Super Bowls on your own. You need to drive a collective accountability among your entire team.
WHAT TO PAY ATTENTION TO:
You may be managing your team’s entire accountability structure out of a misguided sense of control—or because you think there’s no other way.
Take a moment to review these questions and reflect on your own team right now:
- Is all of your team’s accountability anchored on you?
- Do team members commit to setting the tone of accountability and inspire their colleagues to do the same?
- To what extent do you see members of your team holding each other accountable?
Ultimately, the greatest teams share a collective accountability to be the best, to strive to high standards of performance, and to create a positive impact both within the team and across their organizations.
Does Your Team Demonstrate Collective Accountability?
Gut Check for Leaders
RESOURCES TO HELP PUT IT IN ACTION:
- How to Build an Accountable Team ebook (includes a team evaluation!)
- How to Build Community in a Hybrid World ebook (includes community builders manifesto)
More Leadership Resources
We have many resources to help you become the most accountable leader you be, develop accountable leaders on your team, and scale leadership accountability across your organization.
Signup for our monthly newsletter with the latest Gut Check for Leaders, Lead the Future Podcast, and other important leadership accountability news.
